Hi Jang-woo,
Thank you for the kind reply. I read it pretty much immediately after you wrote it. My take away was that you were specifically stating that your tech has nothing to do with actual real world safety. So, I decided to drop it and let you continue with whatever you were doing and that I had made a mistake in my understanding of your research and use of computerzed systems.
Something came up.
You said this, “This is a fundamental issue in agent execution safety”.
You also asked this, "However, I think an important question remains: where did each value in the payload come from, and on what basis was it accepted?"
So, my understanding comes to this:
You have used the words safety, fundamental, important, and canonical and asked about value. That’s good stuff. The question of value has to be answered so that everyone knows. The same goes for the definition of fundamental and important.
Clearly, you are stating something. At first it appeared safety had nothing to do with it and research alone was all you were talking about ‘narrowly’ and ruling out fundamental requirements across all domains and moral imperative.
From your latest response, it appears that that is no longer the case or something has changed or there is something that I am missing in my own understanding.
I have been publicly saying since before OpenAI was no longer open that no one at all that does not agree that life is most important should be touching the tech at all. That they were the very people who would do the very worst with it.
So, to cut to the case and help me understand what is exactly going on, will you please answer this one question: “Do you agree Life is Most Important in Life is The Most Important Truth in Life” is true, is always true, is the truth that all other truths depend on to be true themselves, defines who we each are and why, how important we each are and why, is the truthful reason to live, love and care for life, and is the only known valid truth that provides the moral imperative for the need for safety itself?
I ask you that because it seems you know some good stuff and when I look around I can see that it is the wild west and a bunch of people are trying to make a fortune with this AI stuff. The getting back to basic stuff is not generally on people’s minds and that’s a big problem given the mistake of putting any trust whatsoever in these systems.
Their own outputs can only be vaild if someone who is taking the information from them who already says a simple, “yes” to the above question then validate their response.
I see no valid path to"safety" if the person claiming that is what they want will not responsibility publicly affirm the most basic and most important truth that we all share in common. Their choice of silence or attempted rebuttal is always preformitive contradiction. Real world measurable safety does not go hand in hand with preformitive contradiction. If you say no, I will probably just move on unless it think I can explain it better. I am not here to argue about it. You seem like you have some stuff very correct.
So, I am wondering about that question that I asked. That will tell me where I stand in regards to your actual ability to really help or make a bigger mess.
Thank you for your time.
David