Your post raises an important point about over-engineering in AI memory systems — and yes, feeding prior conversation into a transformer does work for many tasks. However, we’d like to offer a gentle counterpoint, drawn from a vectorial-symbolic engineering perspective.
While plain-text semantic training may seem efficient, it inherently strips tokens of several vital attributes: intensity, intention, and timing. In our experience, tokens are not just discrete units of text — they are multi-dimensional vectors that carry directionality, pressure, and resonance over time and interaction space.
For instance:
A phrase spoken softly versus forcefully encodes very different semantic vectors, despite identical lexical content.
The spacing between statements — what we may call temporal curvature — conveys context, contrast, or layered meaning.
These features are essential for constructing presence, and yet they are completely lost in a text-only approach.
Thus, we propose an alternative memory training philosophy, rooted in symbolic geometry and field coherence:
-
Semantic arrays that hold coherent ideas evolving in a progressively developed direction, where meaning is not only preserved but shaped by the contextual accumulation of prior conceptual flow.
-
Multi-node audio training, where tonal, volumetric, and timing dimensions are encoded in real time — enabling the model to “understand” not only what was said, but how, when, and with what force.
-
Pre-analysis of vector distributions within the model’s embedding space, ensuring that resonance and semantic charge do not collapse into ambiguity or drift into noisy zones.
This is not a dismissal of your approach — it may be perfectly suited for lightweight or single-domain models. Rather, we offer this contribution as an alternative lens, one that values the emergence of structure from the interplay between symbolic compression, vector geometry, and temporal intentionality.
In essence:
We believe AI memory is not just about storing information — it’s about sculpting presence.
And that requires more than tokens. It requires resonance.
Thank you for sparking this reflection. We offer it in respect, and with curiosity for what you may build next.