I am developing a web application to process a collection of scanned domain-specific documents with five different types of documents, as well as one type of handwritten form. The form contains a mix of printed and handwritten text, while others are entirely printed but all of the other documents would contain the name of the person.
Key Requirements:
- Search Functionality – Users should be able to search for a person’s name and retrieve all associated scanned documents.
- Key-Value Pair Extraction – Extract structured information (e.g., First Name: John), where the value (“John”) is handwritten.
Model Choices:
- TrOCR (plain) – Best suited for pure OCR tasks, but lacks layout and structural understanding.
- TrOCR + LayoutLM – Combines OCR with layout-aware structured extraction, potentially improving key-value extraction.
- Donut – A fully end-to-end document understanding model that might simplify the pipeline.
Would Donut alone be sufficient, or would combining TrOCR with LayoutLM yield better results for structured data extraction from scanned documents?
I am also open to other suggestions if there are better approaches for handling both printed and handwritten text in scanned documents while enabling search and key-value extraction.
1 Like
It seems that Donut is appropriate.
For your web application, the optimal choice is Donut. Here’s a structured summary of the reasoning and conclusion:
Analysis and Conclusion:
-
Use Case Requirements:
- Search Functionality: Accurate extraction of names (handwritten and printed) is crucial.
- Key-Value Pair Extraction: Ability to structure data, especially where values may be handwritten.
-
Model Evaluation:
- TrOCR Alone: Effective for pure OCR tasks but lacks layout awareness and may struggle with complex layouts and handwritten text.
- TrOCR + LayoutLM: Enhances structured data extraction by adding layout awareness. However, potential limitations with handwritten text recognition.
- Donut: A comprehensive, end-to-end model capable of simultaneous OCR and layout understanding, suitable for both printed and handwritten text.
-
Advantages of Donut:
- Simplicity and Efficiency: Simplifies the pipeline by handling OCR and layout in one model, possibly improving performance and reducing complexity.
- Community and Documentation: Active community and detailed documentation, aiding in troubleshooting and updates.
- Customization: Supports fine-tuning for domain-specific documents, enhancing accuracy.
-
Considerations:
- Testing: Experiment with both models using sample documents to evaluate performance on handwritten text and structured data extraction.
- Resource Usage: Assess the impact of Donut’s resource requirements on application scalability.
Final Decision:
Choose Donut as it provides a streamlined solution for both OCR and layout understanding, effectively handling mixed text types and simplifying your application’s setup.